Customer Service Desk
Photo by Random Retail from PA, United States on Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 2.0

Returns Policy

Part of Writing a clear store returns process

Reviewing a returns policy with current consumer guidance

Audit an Australian returns policy against ACCC guidance on change of mind, product problems, remedies, proof and return costs.

This is an editorial pen name used by the publication, not a claim of an independently verified personal identity. Original editorial credit: Desk Returns Process.

undefined

Review an Australian returns policy in two passes. First, identify what the store voluntarily offers for change of mind. Then read every sentence as it applies to a customer reporting a product problem. Rewrite wording that suggests voluntary conditions limit consumer-guarantee rights.

The governing law is the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). Use the ACCC's “Consumer guarantees – a guide for consumers” (July 2021) as the reference point; the ACCC, ASIC and state and territory consumer protection agencies have also jointly produced more detailed consumer guarantees guidance for business, legal advisors and consumer representatives.

Identify which promise each sentence makes

Mark each line as a change-of-mind term, a product-problem instruction or a possible-remedy explanation. If a line fits more than one group, clarify its scope.

A store may set a period, product exclusions or packaging conditions for a change-of-mind offer. It must follow the offer it makes.

The ACCC guide lists the situations where a consumer may not be entitled to a remedy, including simply changing their mind, deciding they do not like the purchase or have no use for it, or having a defect drawn to their attention before buying.

Those conditions cannot deny a remedy for a major or minor product problem under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) consumer guarantees. A warranty is an extra promise; its expiry does not by itself end consumer-guarantee rights, which exist regardless of any express warranty given by the manufacturer (lawhandbook.sa.gov.au).

Check prominent headings and short messages as well as the full policy. A qualification several paragraphs below “No refunds on sale items” may not undo the impression created by that line.

Rewrite short lines the same way. “Sale items cannot be returned, exchanged or refunded”, a line the ACCC sweep listed as potentially misleading, becomes “Sale items are not eligible for change-of-mind returns; if a sale item is faulty, your rights under the Australian Consumer Law apply.”

Audit wording that could mislead

In a February 2025 sweep of more than two thousand Australian retail websites, the ACCC reported concerns about faulty-item time limits. It also flagged blanket exclusions for sale or specialised items, manufacturer warranties presented as the only remedy route, and restrictions or fees for faulty-item returns. The sweep reviewed return policies and website terms and conditions, some of which raised concerns as potentially misleading under the Australian Consumer Law.

Write towards the correct position: a store-set window is not a condition of a faulty-goods claim. Under the ACL, businesses should not make statements to the effect that a consumer has a limited timeframe, from receipt of the good, to return the product (ACCC). Where a contract does not fix a time for the supply of services, the guarantee is supply within a reasonable time.

Wording to examineReview question
“No refunds” or “sale items cannot be returned”Is the statement clearly limited to a voluntary change-of-mind offer?
“Report faults within [store period]”Does it wrongly make the store’s period a condition of a consumer-guarantee remedy?
“Unused and in original packaging”Is this restricted to the change-of-mind offer?
“Contact the manufacturer after the warranty expires”Does the store still explain its responsibility for consumer-guarantee claims?
“Customer pays all return postage”Does the policy account for confirmed problems and large, heavy or hard-to-remove faulty items?
“Store credit only”Could it rule out a refund or replacement the customer is entitled to choose?

Worked example. The ACCC sweep quoted this line: “In the unlikely event that your item arrives damaged or faulty, please notify the store within 30 days of delivery to receive a replacement.” Rewrite it as “Contact us about damaged or faulty items; a notice period does not limit your rights under the Australian Consumer Law.”

Check remedies and return instructions

Do not promise an immediate refund for every reported problem. A business may assess the product before providing a remedy, and the Act addresses multiple non-major consumer guarantee failures, so establish which type of failure applies before rewriting the wording.

Where there is a major failure, the consumer chooses the remedy. The ACCC guide lists the choices: return the product and ask for a refund; ask for an identical replacement, or one of similar value if reasonably available; or keep the product and ask for compensation for the drop in value caused by the problem. For a major failure, those rights supersede any attempt to limit liability.

Consumer guarantee rights are separate from any warranties offered by a business and cannot be taken away by anything a business says or does.

The consumer guarantees cannot be excluded, restricted or modified by terms of a contract. Section 64 provides that the guarantees cannot be excluded by contract, except excluding liability for some recreational services, and consumers cannot waive their rights under the ACL even if they agree with the supplier (lawhandbook.sa.gov.au).

Review proof-of-purchase wording. The ACCC educates consumers and businesses about rights and responsibilities under consumer law and can investigate if a business breaks the rules about providing receipts or bills. It does not resolve individual disputes about receipts or bills not being provided.

If a business and a customer cannot resolve a problem, the customer can complain to the consumer protection agency in their state or territory, or to the ACCC (accc.gov.au). The ACCC does not resolve individual disputes about whether the consumer guarantees have been met, or about the remedy.

Compare every policy location

Compare product-page messages, checkout text, FAQs, order emails, return forms and staff reply templates with the revised policy. A careful full policy can still be undermined by a contradictory short message. Record which guidance and date informed the review, and revisit the wording when the store’s terms or official guidance change.

More from Returns Policy